How to Appeal an IRS Decision: A Step-by-Step Guide

Home >    Blog >

How to Appeal an IRS Decision: A Step-by-Step Guide

appeal an IRS decision

Disagree with an IRS decision? Here’s how to appeal an IRS decision and start the appeal process. The IRS sends a detailed examination report to notify individuals about the outcome of an audit. First, make sure you do not sign the IRS examination report. Your next step is to file a written protest to request an appeal. In this guide, we’ll explain each step, provide tips on gathering documentation, and help you navigate the IRS appeals process.

Key Takeaways

  • Taxpayers can appeal IRS decisions through an independent Office of Appeals to contest findings without court involvement, potentially leading to reduced taxes and penalties.
  • To initiate an appeal, taxpayers must file a written protest clearly stating their objections and necessary details, escalating to IRS Form 12203 for disputes over $25,000.
  • Successful appeals require thorough preparation, including gathering supporting documents, maintaining professionalism, and consulting tax professionals for guidance throughout the process.

Understanding the IRS Appeals Process

 

An overview of the IRS appeals process.

The IRS appeals system is designed to resolve tax disputes without the need for court intervention, provided your reasons for appeal align with tax laws. The primary purpose of this process is to give taxpayers a fair opportunity to contest IRS findings without the time and expense of litigation. Many taxpayers find that appealing an IRS decision can lead to a reduction or even elimination of taxes and penalties.

Understanding your rights as a taxpayer is fundamental before beginning the appeal process. These appeal rights equip you to handle interactions with the IRS confidently and effectively. The Office of Appeals significantly boosts taxpayer confidence in the IRS’s fairness and efficiency. Taxpayers or their authorized representative can request conferences to address disputed issues, highlighting the importance of having qualified representation. Taxpayers can request a conference with the appeals office through various means, including correspondence, telephone, or in-person meetings.

The IRS Office of Appeals operates independently from the audit and collection departments, ensuring an impartial review of your case. Appealing often results in reduced assessments for many taxpayers, making it worthwhile if you disagree with the IRS audit findings.

Steps to Initiate an Appeal

To initiate an IRS appeal, first refrain from signing or accepting the IRS examination report. Instead, you must file a written protest to formally request an appeal. Clearly state the specific changes you contest and your reasons in the protest.

For amounts over $25,000, escalate the audit by completing IRS Form 12203 to request an appeal. Filing IRS Form 12203 ensures your appeal is officially recognized and processed by the IRS Office of Appeals.

Required Information for Your Appeal

A formal protest must include specific taxpayer identification information and a clear statement of disagreement with the IRS findings. Sign your written protest to affirm the truthfulness of your statements under penalty of perjury statement.

Include a copy of the proposed tax adjustment and clearly state your reasons for disagreement. This ensures that your appeal is detailed and well-documented, providing a solid foundation for your case.

Submitting a Small Case Request

For disputed amounts of $25,000 or less, you can file a small case request instead of a formal written protest. For amounts between $2,500 and $25,000, it is recommended to submit a written protest labeled as a ‘small case request’ to initiate your appeal.

Submit a brief written statement detailing your disagreement for a small case request. Ensure you submit this request directly to the IRS office that issued the original letter regarding your audit. Clearly state the reasons for your disagreement along with the specific issues in your request.

Preparing for Your IRS Appeal

 

Preparing for your IRS appeal.

Success in an IRS appeal hinges on thorough preparation. Gather necessary supporting documents and consult a tax professional if needed. After your case is assigned to an appeals officer, you will have a minimum of 60 days for preparation. Ensure you use this time wisely. The Office of Appeals aims to explain taxpayer rights, address concerns promptly, and ensure fair service.

Present facts and your interpretation of the law to support your position. Maintain professionalism and respect during discussions with the appeals officer. Answer questions and clarify points during the hearing, providing necessary documentation promptly.

Gathering Supporting Documents

Include your name, address, and contact information in your written protest. Provide supporting facts and the legal basis for your dispute. Request additional documentation from the IRS if needed to support your case. Including your daytime telephone number in your appeal facilitates smoother communication.

Consulting a Tax Professional

A tax professional can significantly strengthen your appeal with their expertise and guidance. If uncertain about settlement conditions or the appeal process, a certified public accountant or tax expert can offer invaluable support.

The IRS Office of Appeals

The IRS Office of Appeals operates independently from audit and collection departments to ensure fair resolutions of tax disputes. It aims to resolve disputes between taxpayers and auditors without court intervention. Appeals officers act as neutral parties, striving for efficient resolutions and encouraging settlements. The independent office of appeals plays a crucial role in this process.

The Office of Appeals can reduce or overturn audit findings made during tax assessments. An appeals officer may also identify additional items not flagged by the auditor, impacting the resolution. Staffed with skilled professionals, many of whom are former auditors.

The core values of independence and impartiality enable objective decision-making in tax disputes. This ensures taxpayers receive a fair and unbiased review of their cases.

Presenting Your Case to the Appeals Officer

Prepare copies of receipts, statements, and other necessary forms, along with accompanying documents, when presenting your case to the appeals officer. Organize information using spreadsheets and visual presentations for clarity. Clearly articulate any errors made by the auditor during your presentation.

Appeals case hearings are informal, which may affect your presentation style. Take meticulous notes if the hearing is not recorded to track discussions. Maintain professionalism by avoiding negative remarks about the auditor or IRS during the hearing.

Negotiating a Settlement

The goal of appeals officers during the negotiation process is to resolve cases quickly and efficiently, reaching a settlement. During negotiations, initially discuss adjustments and percentages rather than specific dollar amounts. Ask for a waiver of penalties during negotiations.

Fully understand the terms of a settlement before signing any agreements. Resolve disagreements with IRS outcomes through negotiation or adjustment requests.

What If You Disagree With the Outcome?

If you disagree with the settlement offered, negotiate for clarification or adjustments with supporting arguments. Rejecting a settlement offer may delay the process and result in increased penalties.

Consult a tax professional if you’re uncomfortable with the settlement terms. If you disagree with the IRS’s final decision, consider taking your case to Tax Court.

Missed Deadlines and Extensions

File your appeal within 30 days of receiving the IRS notice to avoid penalties. Submit a written protest within the deadline specified in the IRS correspondence.

If you miss the initial 30-day deadline, request a 30 or 60-day extension, which is often approved.

What Happens If You Lose Your Appeal?

If your appeal fails, you are liable for the original tax amount, plus penalties and interest. After losing your appeal, negotiate a payment plan with the IRS or consider pursuing further action in Tax Court. A payment plan can help you manage your financial obligations by spreading the payments over a period of time, making it easier to cope with the tax burden. Additionally, exploring options such as an Offer in Compromise might be beneficial if you are unable to pay the full amount owed. This option allows you to settle your tax debt for less than the full amount, depending on your circumstances.

Consulting with a tax professional can provide guidance on the best course of action tailored to your financial situation. Furthermore, if you choose to pursue the matter in Tax Court, be prepared for a more formal legal process, which may involve additional costs and time. It’s important to weigh the potential benefits against

 

Summary

This article has outlined the essential steps and considerations for appealing an IRS decision. Understanding the IRS appeals process is crucial for effectively resolving tax disputes without resorting to court action. We urge readers to take proactive steps in preparing their appeals and to seek professional assistance if needed to ensure a thorough and well-supported case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you file an appeal with the IRS?

Yes, you can file an appeal with the IRS if you disagree with their decision. This process allows you to contest the change through the IRS’s independent Appeals Office without going to tax court.

How much will the IRS usually settle for?

The IRS typically settles for an amount based on your financial capacity, considering your assets, income, monthly expenses, and savings. Therefore, the settlement amount can vary significantly from person to person.

Are IRS Appeals successful?

IRS Appeals can be successful, often resulting in a reduction of tax liability for taxpayers who negotiate effectively. Many dismiss the appeal process, but substantial savings can often be achieved.

What to do if I disagree with the IRS decision?

If you disagree with an IRS decision, you have the right to appeal it through the IRS Independent Office of Appeals or seek external litigation in federal court. Ensure that you file your formal protest within 30 days of the IRS’s decision and prepare your case thoroughly.

What should I do first if I disagree with an IRS audit?

If you disagree with an IRS audit, first, do not sign the examination report and file a written protest to express your disagreement. This formal step is essential in addressing your concerns.

____________________________

For more information about the tax and accounting services we provide, visit our Home Page!  The friendly CPAs, Enrolled Agents, tax professionals, and bookkeepers and accountants at Massey and Company CPA are here to assist you.

If you want my team and I to handle your tax matter for you, click here.

You are welcome to email me directly at gary.massey@masseyandcompanyCPA.com.


Massey and Company CPA is a boutique tax and accounting firm serving individuals and small businesses in AtlantaChicago and throughout the country.  Our services include tax return preparation, tax planning for businesses and individuals, estates and trusts, IRS tax problem resolution, IRS auditssales taxes, small business accounting, and bookkeeping clean up services

Check out our 5-Star Google reviews here!

Massey and Company CPA

Based in Atlanta and Chicago, Massey and Company CPA specializes in tax and accounting matters of small businesses, entrepreneurs, and their families.
 
We do everything related to tax return preparation and tax planning, as well as accounting and bookkeeping for small businesses using QuickBooks Online.
 
In addition, we represent taxpayers before the IRS, keeping taxpayers out of tax trouble. We negotiate with the IRS and the state, so you do not have to.
 
We know the tax issues. We know our way around the IRS. We know QuickBooks. And we know how to help you save taxes and keep more of your hard-earned profits.

Recent Posts